StartUp Founders: PMF - Phantom Market Fit đź‘»


Hey Reader,

Founders looking for PMF are never going to find it. At best, you'll catch a fleeting moment where everything aligns - right product, right problem, right time. Until it's not. (𝕏)

Build a product so f'n good, be so in tune with your customers, be so fast to iterate on the feedback, that PMF is forced to find you.

TL;DR PMF is not a destination; it's a relentless, evolving, endless chase. Deceptive POSITIVE data is the kryptonite. (Workbook)

Every Founder/StartUp Needs A Newsletter

Communicate authority, deliver value, and nurture relationships. Whether you're building in public, establishing expertise, or growing your audience, a newsletter is key to sustained engagement.

​

Turn old leads into new opportunities. Drive long-term growth with consistent, valuable content.

​
​ConvertKit empowers you to build and nurture relationships, driving long-term growth and engagement.

Want to get in front of 140,000+ founders at $3 CPC? Go here.

LAST WEEKS FRAMEWORK:

​4.3 Sales Pre-Objections: Silent Deal Killers​

LETS GET INTO IT:

Every founder who’s made it will tell you: customer obsession, observability, and feedback are the holy trinity. Everything else is noise, including your mythical quest for PMF.

PMF is a motion, a north star, a result of your work, research, experience, ignorance, arrogance, luck, and timing. It’s the outcome of relentless experimentation.

Most founders mistake early adopter enthusiasm for true market fit. Confusing vitamins with painkillers. You can be in revenue, have happy customers, have growth, all without PMF. It's this transition to capturing that increased market share at velocity that defines PMF.

It's the moment the market is desperate to buy (exchange value) what you’re selling and users are consistent (rabid) in their usage. This means the customers you want are not likely the customers you can have. Big companies are rarely desperate for anything.

PMF Defined (If You Must)

  • Growth in Revenue or Value: When market demand drives exponential growth. More than revenue; it's about clear, sustainable value creation. Revenue, active users, or monetizable data, you're seeing rapid growth and a working economic model.
    ​
  • Right Customers at Velocity: Sales volume or user growth alone isn’t enough. You need to acquire the RIGHT customers at speed. It has to be retentive. Without retention, no matter how much they like it, what’s the point of finding more users?
    ​
  • Market Size That Matters: It's more than current demand. It’s the long-term market opportunity. If your TAM is smaller than you realize or want, you need to run into adjacent markets/SKUs that are big enough to matter.

PMF is not a one-time, permanent achievement. Complacency kills. Markets shift, customer needs shift, and what worked yesterday can fail tomorrow, and tomorrow, is literally tomorrow.

You have to perpetually validate, revalidate, revalidate, revalidate that your product solves a real, urgent problem. Anticipate changes and adapt faster than anyone else - before you fall OUT of PMF.

​Chasing Product Market Fit (& Catching It)​

Brutal Truths

When you hit real PMF, you’ll know it. Customers are coming to you and demand exceeds your capability to supply. You’re sole job (not your sole job) pivots to recruiting. You are just trying to keep up. If you’re not feeling that, you’re not there yet.

BPMF vs APMF… Your business pre-PMF and post-PMF are two different companies. Before, you’re scrambling. After, you’re scaling. APMF is when you realize the competencies and team that got you here, might not be the team to take you there.

  • Feedback: Listen to every complaint, every suggestion, every opportunity to see, to watch, to understand, to learn.
    ​
  • Data: Metrics tell you everything. Engagement, churn, NPS - combined with the voice of the customer tell a story. If you read it.

You can create innovation in a garage, but the market defines if it’s innovative. The market is the ultimate judge of your product’s value and relevance.

As always, if I can be of service, feel free to grab time with me.

(YC23 StartUp: It was the most useful advice I’ve received so far - both candid and actionable. Within 5 minutes of the call, it’s apparent that James is the real deal.)

-- James

Off topic. I'm thinking of converting all these modules into a cohesive live course, from idea origination to first customers, literally pebble by pebble. Would this be helpful? (also, if you are a wizard at this stuff, reach out)

​

Not A Subscriber?

Join 140k+ StartUp Founders reading my weekly newsletter offering tactical insights to start, scale, and fund their startup. Real advice from a 3x exited founder.

​


​

‪8424 Santa Monica Blvd, Suite A523, Los Angeles, CA 90069
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

StartUp To ScaleUp

Where 140k+ founders read my weekly newsletter offering tactical insights to start, scale, and fund their startup. Real advice from a 3x exited founder & author of the #1 Best Seller "Starting A StartUp | Build Something People Want."

Read more from StartUp To ScaleUp
Clarity Then Sanity

Hey Reader, Last week we agreed December decides your 2026 fate. We're still in December. So a quick reminder to act like it. Perhaps a little more bias for action... Close deals. Send updates. Align your team. Show gratitude. Build your strategy. But, I missed a pretty critical point that is so easily overlooked... None of it matters if you're executing on the wrong business. You can do everything right. Close the deals, ship the features, hit the milestones and still not feel like you are...

December Decides

Hey Reader, Every founder has an imaginary list called “I’ll get to that in December.” It follows you all year while you're in the trenches, this dumping ground for everything you don’t have time for but swear you’ll handle when things “calm down.” Do I need to list them, or are we on the same page... So. Funny story. December is here. Four weeks to do nine weeks of work... The stuff you pushed off, the stuff you forgot, the stuff you should’ve done already, and the stuff you promised...

First Belief

Hey Reader, The very first thing every founder says before the product exists, a single customer or dollar shows up, before any proof of any kind is some version of: I can do this. It's rarely evidence led, something inside you decides it's worth believing. It's not fraud. It's not delusion. It's simply the starting point. And this is really important. Founding rarely begins with real data. It begins with a belief you have no business holding yet and then spending years trying to earn it -...